Slippery slope argument, in logic, the fallacy of arguing that a certain course of action is undesirable or that a certain proposition is implausible because it leads to an undesirable or implausible conclusion via a series of tenuously connected premises, each of which is understood to lead. Give an example of a slideslope that is not a slippery slope fallacy. For example, a slippery slope argument could involve saying that if we allow a relatively minor event to take place now, then a major and tragic. Why we should avoid the slippery slope books the guardian. A slippery slope is an argument that suggests that a certain initial action could lead to a chain of events with a relatively extreme result, or that if we treat one case a certain way then we will have to treat more extreme cases the same way too. Common fallacies logical and critical thinking futurelearn. According to the fallacy files, a slippery slope argument is an example of an informal fallacy.
The second amendment to the united states constitution states that a well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed. In this wireless philosophy video, joseph wu university of cambridge introduces you to the slippery slope argument. I fail to understand why they identify the slippery slope as a fallacy, and then say what they do. In this fallacy, a person makes a claim that one event leads to another event and so on until we come to some awful conclusion. Slippery slope arguments lack a theory that makes the likelihood of valid extrapolation logical. If jacobs hangs for witch he forfeits up his propertythats law. It is only a fallacy if i do not give good reasons for why this slide will occur, or if there are no good reasons for why the end of the chain is undesirable. It was illustrated by brett helquist and released on september 23, 2003. But since this case comes from the same precincts that gave us gay marriage will lead to incest and manondog sex, i suppose i shouldnt be surprised.
The exact nature of such an argument can consist of nothing more than the beginning and ending situations, with few intermediary events. This argument is that when one event occurs, other related events will follow, and this slippery slope will eventually lead to undesirable consequences. The crucible slippery slope example my proof is there. Today, id like to describe another kind of fallacy that arises because of the phenomenon of vagueness. One of the most common ways in which this fallacy can occur is through the process of someone creating causality where none exists. In one type of this fallacy, the problem arises by thinking that a claim must be true because it hasnt been shown to be false. If we let our child out of his room, eventually he will want to.
In the last lecture we saw how the phenomenon of vagueness, gives rise to a kind of fallacy that we called a conceptual slippery slope. The slippery slope fallacy is an argument that claims that if one thing happens or is allowed to happen. Its perfectly legitimate to point out that a certain action carries along with it an obligation of moral consistency. Dual credit english slippery slope project by mark and josh. Whats so fallacious about the slippery slope fallacy.
Surely we dont want to say that a slippery slope argument necessarily has a false. Slippery slope critical thinking fallacies wireless. Making a slippery slope fallacy, one makes a chain of events that doesnt necessarily factually check out. When i first posted my description of the slippery slope fallacy, i had a sneaking suspicion that some nra supporters would get defensive at the fact that i cited a common pronra argument as an example of the slippery slope fallacy. In order to get something out quick, i decided to not make very many slides and kind of gave up on slides half way through. The slippery slope fallacy a weak inductive prediction of dire consequences. How to avoid the slippery slope fallacy in arguments and. The logical structure of this fallacy is as follows. This argument is that when one event occurs, other related events will follow. Taco bell waffle taco tv spot, slippery slope submissions should come only from the actors themselves, their parentlegal guardian or casting agency. So, lets assign some rough probability estimates to. Fairness slippery slopes fallacies of unclarity coursera. A slippery slope argument ssa, in logic, critical thinking, political rhetoric, and caselaw, is often viewed as a logical fallacy in which a party asserts that a relatively small first step leads to a chain of related events culminating in some significant usually negative effect. Choose from 49 different sets of slippery slope fallacies flashcards on quizlet.
Jan 15, 20 forbes takes privacy seriously and is committed to transparency. Much of what was repulsive 100 years ago is normal today, and although it may be a slippery slope what is repulsive today is possible to be normal 100 years into tomorrow. Usually the slippery slope fallacy is related to fearmongering when used about drugs, or gay marriage, or even dating that leads to sex. Can the argument used in the slipperyslope fallacy ever be used legitimately. A tricky precarious situation, especially one that leads gradually but inexorably to disaster.
Learn slippery slope fallacies with free interactive flashcards. Ysee he buy a pig of my wife four or five year ago, and the pig died soon after. Mar 10, 2015 and again, that might very well not be true. People use the slippery slope fallacy because they want to link together. It is designed to help students understand the physical, legal, societal, educational and familial impact of drugs. Fallacy of the week slippery slope fallacy steel on steel. Critically thinking about the slippery slope fallacy. So when you find this kind of argument in progress, seek that theory. The slippery slope fallacy based on the idea that an object placed at the top of a slippery slope will slide all the way to the bottom if given even a small nudge, the slippery slope fallacy means arguing that even a small step taken in one direction will lead to some drastic consequence. Jan 16, 2018 the slippery slope argument is an argument where one action is argued to start a chain of events that will result in undesirable consequences. The slippery slope fallacy is an argument that claims that if one thing happens or is allowed to happen, then that will lead to other steps and ultimately.
This argument usually ignores the individual connections between events in favor of simply linking one. Gun rights and the slippery slope fallacy the bull elephant. The bottom of the slope might not be that bad and do the costs outweigh the benefits are not the main problems with a slippery slope fallacy. A slippery slope fallacy is an argument in which someone presents a statement that one act or event must eventually lead to another, without proof to support this series of events.
Our argument is qol changes are worse for the classic. The discussion should be led by a teacher, guidance counselor, therapist, parent, or other responsible adult. Logical fallacy slippery slope synonyms, logical fallacy slippery slope pronunciation, logical fallacy slippery slope translation, english dictionary definition of logical fallacy slippery slope. But, if the causal claim of a slippery slope argument is true, then the argument may well be a very good argument. Its a logical fallacy because this does not follow that. The notion behind slippery slope arguments is that we shouldnt do something such as a because a will lead to b, and b will lead to c and so on until we end up with something bad. Slippery slope fallacy synonyms, slippery slope fallacy pronunciation, slippery slope fallacy translation, english dictionary definition of slippery slope fallacy. Sunk cost fallacy is getting into something and not. Choose from 54 different sets of slippery slope fallacy flashcards on quizlet. Apr 02, 2015 why we should avoid the slippery slope. The slippery slope argument causal slippery slope argument. The slippery slope fallacy critical thinking notes. A couple of recent news stories and the responses they have generated got me thinking once again about the slippery slope fallacy, whereby an event is presented as the catalyst for a chain of.
Some slippery slopes are real, but often theyre not, and thats when weve got a slippery slope fallacy on our hands. This fallacy is often used in order to influence ones decision one way or another. Created by spring 2012 honors critical thinking students. If a score of 70% is passing, then by premise two, a score of 69.
You are using a strawman fallacy while complaining about us using a slippery slope fallacy. This distinction is useful for understanding the fallacies in wiphis critical thinking. Slippery slope fallacy definition of slippery slope fallacy. Its also important to note that the slippery slope fallacy is not incrementalism. Jan 20, 2012 the fallacy is identified by an increasing number of vaguely defined steps between cause and effect to draw out an emotional response. What is the fallacy of begging the question answer the. The slippery slope argument is an argument that concludes that if an action is taken, other negative consequences will follow. The arguer then concludes that we therefore shouldn. In the last two lectures, we saw how the phenomenon vagueness gives rise to a couple different kinds of fallacy. Nov 24, 2011 this is an archetypical slippery slope argument. To analyze this kind of reasoning, we need to examine each link in the chain. The strawman you are making is that we are arguing that yes, qol changes are better for the classic experience but they will lead to a slippery slope that is not our argument. This is a sample video from a video tutorial course titled fallacies, one of many videos on critical.
The fallacy of arguing that a lack of evidence proves something. Cassie martin and shayna porter example in the crucible act ii, page 3435 giles. The technique is fallacious as when its only purpose is to scare the opponent when two categories are unrelated, but one of them is controversial. By definition, a slippery slope is a logical device, but it is usually known under its fallacious form, in which a person asserts that some event must inevitably follow from another without any rational argument or demonstrable mechanism for the inevitability of the. Slippery slippery slippery slippery slope slippery slippery slippery slippery slope slippery slippery slippery slippery slope slippery slippery slippery slippery slope goldfish in a bowl got my brain full of holes left half right half no ones in charge here goldfish in a bowl got my hands covered in blood and i cannot stop this hemorrhage. One such fallacy i have not touched upon is the slippery slope.
Jun 19, 2019 the slippery slope is a fallacy, says jacob e. The fact that i list the causal version of the slippery slope as a fallacy does not mean that every argument with the form of a slippery slope is fallacious. Van fleet, precisely because we can never know if a whole series of events andor a certain result is determined to follow one event or action in particular. But in its barest bones, a slipperyslope argument is of the following form. When is the slippery slope argument fallacious and when is itif ever compelling.
The slippery slope fallacy consists of arguments that reason if something s were to happen, then something else p will eventually occur, so we should prohibit s from happening example of slippery slope. When is the slippery slope argument fallacious and when is itif evercompelling. The slippery slope of substance abuse is an example of authentic learning. A slippery slope argument is one in which a small first step will lead through a series of other steps to some inevitable outcome. A slippery slope argument ssa, in logic, critical thinking, political rhetoric, and caselaw, is a logical fallacy in which a party asserts that a relatively small first step leads to a chain of related events culminating in some significant usually negative effect. Taco bell waffle taco tv commercial, slippery slope. We have provided a related file for you to download. Slippery slope fallacy flashcards and study sets quizlet. Its not, in and of itself, a fallacy despite many claims youll find in texts on rhetoric. This is a great example of the slippery slope fallacy, done for humorous effect. Slippery slope fallacy with napoleon dynamite characters. For example, if event x were to occur, then event y would. Jan 21, 2014 dual credit english slippery slope project by mark and josh.
The prediction in this fallacy is always based on mere possibility, not probability. Today, were going to see how that same phenomenon of vagueness gives rise to another kind of fallacy. If the likelihood of progression actually is logical, this is no longer a slippery slope fallacy, but a weak scientific assertion. Videos examples youtube slippery slope definition thank you for watching. A red herring occurs when something is introduced to an argument that misleads or distracts from the relevant issue. Well its a fallacy because it assumes that it cant be fair to fail someone whose score is not significantly different from a passing score, right. Causal slippery slopes fallacies of unclarity coursera. Now you can learn to understand native speakers, expand your vocabulary, and improve your pronunciation. An in formal fallacy is one that is not formal, that is, it is a type of fallacy in which the content of the argument is relevant to its fallacious ness, or which is fallacious for epistemological, dialectical, or pragmatic reasons. In another type, the breakdown in logic comes when you argue that a claim must be false because it hasnt been proved to be true.
If you legalized gay marriage, then they will want you to legalize marriage to animals. Consider the question of whether or not we can correctly say that a human fetus is a human being. This may well be the most useful book you ever read. The critical thinking miniseries was made possible by our viewers and listeners. Slippery slope arguments are fallacious if it is possible to stop at one of the steps.
So that is why this is a fairness slippery slope argument. Coauthored by gabriel weinberg, ceo of duckduckgo and an advisor to the school of thought, it explains over 300 mental models with surprising clarity. Every time i pointed out that this was a slippery slope argument, i was met with a so what. Please include at least one socialwebsite link containing a recent photo of the actor. Logical fallacyslippery slope definition of logical. Those familiar with the phrase slippery slope understand that there is an important third word that ought to be added to the end and that word is fallacy. Learn slippery slope fallacy with free interactive flashcards. Were going to call this the causal slippery slope fallacy. The core of the slippery slope argument is that a specific decision under debate is likely to result in unintended consequences. A slippery slope fallacy occurs when someone makes a claim about a series of events that would lead to one major event, usually a bad event. Unless this argument is accompanied by evidence or argumentation that the legalization of gay marriage removes all constraints upon the other forms of marriage cited, this is a slippery slope fallacy. The slippery slope of anger, gossip, avoidance, control. Thousands of youtube videos with englishchinese subtitles. This fallacy is committed whenever someone misrepresents an opponents claim in arguing against it.
Slippery slope logical fallacy by cassie martin on prezi. Mar 08, 2016 a couple of recent news stories and the responses they have generated got me thinking once again about the slippery slope fallacy, whereby an event is presented as the catalyst for a chain of. Progressives have an agenda to move people from one paradigm to another slowly, without much notice or resistance. Slippery slope critical thinking fallacies youtube. A slippery slope argument ssa, in logic, critical thinking, political rhetoric, and caselaw, is often viewed as a logical fallacy. Fallacies that violate the rules of rational argumentation. Apr 05, 2020 a slippery slope fallacy can also occur as a result of someone using two states that have a difference between them, which is hard to define, to argue that one state does not exist. Hence, a slippery slope is committed when a person argues that some event or practice he or she disapproves of will trigger a sequence of events that will ultimately lead to some undesirable. I should clarify that slippery slope is not in itself a fallacy, but a logical fallacy is created when a slippery slope argument is used where it doesnt actually exist. In typical examples, the argument is political, intended to force the speaker into. Take, for example, the argument that if gay marriage is allowed, then people will want to marry objects or animals. The slippery slope fallacy is an argument that utilizes the false assumption that once a first step is taken, one can predict the next step, which then leads to the next step until some conclusion is reached that leads from the initial step.
Some of the slippery slopes are extremely obvious, but then there are those slippery slopes that are less obvious but potentially more dangerous to life. It happens to everyone of us, even though we may not even realize it sometimes. Jul 02, 2015 ive discussed logical fallacies in my column in the past. Derek gossett and bekah lancaster definition also known as the camels nose a fallacy in which a person asserts that some event must inevitably follow from another without any argument for the inevitability of the event in question. Let me say, in general, when someone gives a fairness slippery slope argument in ordinary life, they usually dont lay it out in the way im laying out these arguments. An idea or course of action which will lead to something unacceptable, wrong, or disastrous. If you look up the article on the slippery slope as a logical fallacy, this gun registration argument is. Fallacies logical fallacies slippery slope is a logical fallacy where one event is said to lead to another event, which in turn leads to another event, which in. The conceptual slippery slope fallacy and the fairness slippery slope fallacy. Usually, but not always, the slippery slope argument is used as a fear tactic informal logical fallacies, 2011. In this challenge, we hang on onto a giant wall thats covered in soap.
Dec 08, 2017 in this wireless philosophy video, joseph wu university of cambridge introduces you to the slippery slope argument. I was actually having this exact discussion on two separate occasions while i was in quebec in october. I am inclined to believe that a negative answer is correct. And there is none but putnam with the coin to buy so great a piece. In the field of informal logic, the slipperyslope argument is a fallacy when the endpoint does not follow necessarily from the initial step, which. It is a fallacy because the claimed outcome is usually not the only possible result of that first step. Arguing that banning bump stocks puts us on a slippery slope to banning all guns is a logical fallacy.
942 1205 1474 738 1500 552 308 342 576 1197 1464 327 487 183 1091 1377 920 1545 1391 356 610 1514 1295 42 845 408 876 167 1205 566 29 1128 906 993 988 86 205 1236 968 567 1210 1166 1407 533 17 1445 188 1160